COURSE 02 / TEACHER GUIDE
The seasons
What really causes the seasons?
Axial tilt changes day length and sunlight angle through the orbit, with opposite patterns in the two hemispheres.
01 / PREPARE
Give students a question worth testing.
Learning objectives
- Compare symmetric latitudes at June and December solstices while controlling the other settings.
- Explain how day length and a higher noon Sun contribute to seasonal solar energy differences.
- Use a zero-tilt comparison to evaluate the claim that changing Earth-Sun distance causes the seasons.
What success looks like
- I can compare evidence from 40 degrees N and 40 degrees S at the same date.
- I can connect a hemisphere's summer to longer days and a higher noon Sun.
- I can explain the result of removing tilt in this circular-orbit model.
Prepare the room
- One browser device per pair, or one teacher device and a projector.
- Student worksheet, pencil and optional two colors for the hemispheres.
- Optional flashlight and a sheet of paper for a beam-area demonstration.
Set up the experiment
- Open /lab/seasons. Pause both Rotation and Orbit before setting comparisons.
- Use the model's June solstice preset and an axial tilt of 23.5 degrees. These are model settings, not a prediction for a named calendar year.
- Compare 40 degrees N and 40 degrees S using the same longitude. Read Day length and compare the Sun near local solar noon.
- Use December solstice with the same settings, then change only axial tilt to 0 degrees for the final comparison.
- Check that students keep symmetric latitudes and do not compare noon in one hemisphere with midnight in the other.
02 / TEACH
A 35-minute lesson.
Let a prediction become a fair comparison, then an explanation grounded in what students observed.
Predict
Teacher moveAsk what season a place at 40 degrees S should have when a place at 40 degrees N has summer. Record whether students cite tilt, distance or hemisphere.
Student taskPredict the day-length pattern for the two hemispheres at the June setting. Keep the reasoning visible for later revision.
Look forA prediction distinguishes both hemispheres instead of using summer as a universal month label.
Set a fair comparison
Teacher movePause Rotation and Orbit. Show how the solstice presets change orbital position and how the tilt control changes a different variable. Set 23.5 degrees and compare symmetric latitudes at a shared longitude.
Student taskIdentify the axis, equator and sunlight direction. State which settings will remain fixed and what will be compared.
Look forPairs use 40 degrees N/S and separate changing the date from changing axial tilt.
Investigate
Teacher moveGuide June, December and zero-tilt trials. Ask pairs to read numerical day length and to compare the Sun at local solar noon. Require both measurements and a visual observation.
Student taskRecord both hemispheres for each trial. Set tilt to 0 degrees and revisit June/December without changing latitude. Swap driver and recorder roles.
Look forThe table contains a reversed solstice pattern and a documented zero-tilt comparison.
Explain with energy
Teacher moveLink longer daylight to more receiving time and higher Sun angle to energy concentrated over a smaller area. Ask why a shared Earth-Sun distance cannot explain opposite seasons at the same moment.
Student taskWrite an explanation using two day-length values and sunlight angle. Challenge the distance claim and revise the prediction.
Look forThe explanation includes both energy duration and angle, without treating animation brightness as a measured temperature.
Check and transfer
Teacher moveUse the exit ticket individually. Invite an equinox comparison if time allows. Revisit the distinction between astronomical seasons and local weather.
Student taskExplain the zero-tilt result and choose evidence that rules out a distance-only claim. Name one model limitation.
Look forStudents use a causal comparison and avoid claiming that all real weather would disappear at zero tilt.
03 / RESPOND & ADAPT
Use the model to challenge a claim.
Summer happens because Earth is much closer to the Sun.
Compare both hemispheres at one orbital position: they share essentially the same Earth-Sun distance while their day lengths and seasons differ. Use tilt as the explanation.
June is summer everywhere.
Use June solstice and December solstice as date labels. Ask students to identify the hemisphere before naming its astronomical season.
Earth's axis changes from 23.5 degrees to 0 degrees at an equinox.
Keep tilt at 23.5 degrees while changing the date. The axis keeps roughly the same direction through this annual orbit; its relation to incoming sunlight changes.
No axial seasons means no weather or temperature differences.
The zero-tilt test removes an astronomical annual pattern in this simplified model. Latitude, atmosphere, geography and oceans still matter in the real world.
Differentiation
Scaffold
Color-code the two hemispheres. Read the day-length values aloud. Use the frame: In June, ___ has longer days than ___. This happens because ___. Ask students to draw the axis before explaining.
Extend
Compare 0, 23.5 and 40 degrees tilt at the same two latitudes. Predict how stronger tilt changes annual contrast, then test. Extend to high latitudes while treating exact poles as special cases.
Access
Offer a shared projected experiment or teacher-read observation set. Allow a spoken claim with a labeled hemisphere diagram. Keep controls paused while students transcribe values; do not require rapid visual tracking.
One step further
Keep tilt at 23.5 degrees. Compare 40 degrees N and 40 degrees S at a March or September equinox. Which properties are similar? Is the Sun directly overhead at both places? Explain.
Suggested extension response
The symmetric latitudes have approximately equal day lengths and equal noon Sun altitude in the idealized geometry. Both have about 12 daylight hours and a noon Sun altitude near 50 degrees. The Sun is not overhead at 40 degrees N/S; near an equinox the overhead point is near the equator. Real sunrise lengths differ slightly because of refraction and the Sun's apparent size.
04 / ASSESS
Look for a reason, backed by evidence.
Observation checks
- June at 23.5 degrees: 40 degrees N about 14.8 h; 40 degrees S about 9.2 h. The Northern Hemisphere has the higher noon Sun.
- December at 23.5 degrees: 40 degrees N about 9.2 h; 40 degrees S about 14.8 h. The Southern Hemisphere has the higher noon Sun.
- Zero tilt: about 12 h at both tested latitudes through the circular orbit, with No axial seasons displayed. This comparison excludes exact poles.
Worksheet answer key
Suggested explanations, rather than exact wording students must copy.
1. How does the solstice pattern reverse between the hemispheres? Use at least two measured values.
At the June setting, 40 degrees N has about 14.8 daylight hours and 40 degrees S about 9.2. December reverses the values: about 9.2 at 40 degrees N and 14.8 at 40 degrees S. The summer hemisphere also has the higher noon Sun.
2. How do longer days and a higher noon Sun help explain summer heating?
Longer days allow solar energy to arrive for more time. A higher noon Sun directs the same beam onto a smaller surface area, increasing energy per unit area. The model supports the geometry; it does not measure actual air temperature.
3. What changed when tilt was set to 0 degrees? Explain the result and one limit of this model.
The readout becomes No axial seasons. At the tested non-polar latitudes, day length is about 12 hours and noon Sun angle loses its annual tilt-driven variation in the circular orbit. This does not remove latitude differences or simulate all real weather; exact poles remain horizon edge cases.
Exit ticket
Exit 1: Why can a distance-only explanation not account for opposite seasons at the same time?
Both hemispheres are on the same Earth and share essentially the same Earth-Sun distance at a given moment, yet their light duration and angles differ. Tilt accounts for the opposite seasonal pattern.
Exit 2: An equinox occurs. Should you change axial tilt from 23.5 degrees to 0 degrees to model it? Explain.
No. Keep the tilt at 23.5 degrees and change orbital position to an equinox preset. Over the annual orbit, the axis remains tilted; its orientation relative to incoming sunlight changes.
Quick rubric
| Criterion | Secure | Developing | Revisit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Comparison | Uses symmetric latitudes and identifies a reversed June/December pattern with values. | Identifies the pattern but omits a hemisphere or measured evidence. | Treats June as summer everywhere or changes several variables at once. |
| Energy mechanism | Links both daylight duration and Sun angle to solar energy received. | Explains one mechanism but not both. | Uses distance alone or treats the display as a temperature measurement. |
| Causal model | Explains zero tilt and recognizes weather, circular orbit or polar limitations. | Describes zero tilt but overgeneralizes to real weather. | Sets tilt to zero to represent an equinox or makes no causal link. |
05 / MODEL & SOURCES
Be clear about what the model can show.
- The orbit is circular and the model isolates tilt-driven effects. Real Earth's orbit is slightly elliptical; distance is not the main explanation of opposite hemispheric seasons.
- The June setting at 23.5 degrees gives approximately 14.8 daylight hours at 40 degrees N and 9.2 at 40 degrees S; December reverses the pattern. These are model values, not civil sunrise forecasts.
- At 0 degrees tilt the display states No axial seasons. Away from the exact poles, day length is approximately 12 hours and noon Sun angle has no annual tilt-driven change in this circular model.
- Exact poles are special horizon cases at zero tilt. With Earth's ordinary tilt, high latitudes may show polar day or night. Do not interpret a horizon-edge readout as an ordinary 12-hour day.
- Sunlight angle and duration help explain heating, but the model does not calculate weather, ocean heat storage or the delay between a solstice and the warmest day.
Vocabulary
- axial tilt
- The angle between Earth's rotation axis and a line perpendicular to its orbital plane.
- hemisphere
- One half of Earth, here north or south of the equator.
- solstice
- A point in the year with a hemisphere's most extreme annual day length.
- equinox
- A point in the year when the two hemispheres receive a nearly symmetric pattern of direct sunlight.
- noon Sun angle
- The Sun's altitude above the local horizon at solar noon; a higher angle concentrates energy over a smaller area.
Scientific background
Course content reviewed 2026-10-04. The online guide and downloadable PDFs use the same course source.